Discussion about this post

User's avatar
PolicyViews Guy's avatar

The Russians played their old Viet Nam playbook in Afghanistan. And that’s exactly why we should be tuning the Russians up at every turn in Ukraine. Payback’s a bitch.

Expand full comment
Valerii Terentev's avatar

Trumps Deals are Fake, so are Putin's

National Security Advisor Mike Waltz is re-appearing from the Signal Gate, he said: “Rather than trying to correct the president of the United States, and the vice president, in the Oval Office, when he [Zelensky] was invited there for the first meeting, and could have sat side-by-side with the president, signing a minerals deal that bound our economies together for the foreseeable future. You want to talk about a security guarantee? That would have been phenomenal. I think that was a historic and missed opportunity.”

This is false.

First, Trump administration officials led by Walz have repeatedly stated that the US would not give Ukraine security guarantees protecting Ukraine against Russia under any circumstances.

Second, the Trump administration signed a minerals agreement with a democratic government in Afghanistan, claimed that it would solidify US support to Afghanistan, and then signed a deal with the Taliban committing the US to remove all forces from Afghanistan. The Trump administration excluded Afghanistan’s government from participation in its talks with the Taliban.

Background:

In 2017, the White House, led by US President Donald J. Trump, signed a minerals development agreement with the then-in-power Afghan government led by Ashraf Ghani.

The September 2017 agreement gave US big business near-monopoly access to development of an estimated $1 trillion mineral reserves in Afghanistan. Both sides called the agreement a critical underpinning for long-term US commitment to Afghanistan.

In 2020, the Trump White House negotiated a withdrawal agreement with the Taliban – at the time a terrorist organization the US was at war with – committing America to withdraw all US forces from Afghan on a hard deadline. The Trump administration cut the deal over the strident objections of the democratically elected Afghan government led by Ghani, whose representatives were excluded from the White House-Taliban negotiations.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts